Design thinking and culture
Does your company deliver services, or deal with customers of any kind? Do you have employees operating machines and tools? The answer is probably yes, and if so, chances are you’ve encountered or at least heard about Design Thinking in relation to your business. This is not unlikely, as Design Thinking is employed in all manners of companies in solving problems with human centered and complex problems (Kolko, 2015). Design Thinking methods are also to some degree interchangeable with company culture.
What exactly is Design Thinking and why are companies using it?
Well, it is defined as both a process and an individual characteristic, or in other words, refers to certain kinds of methods, but also an individual sensibility, which all links design with business. At the hearth of this design approach is the human experience. It is all about understanding, often particularly difficult problems, through empathy with the user and generating and exploring novel ideas to find a solution through various means.
In practice, this approach often encompasses observation, collaboration, often across disciplines, fast learning, visualization and rapid concept prototyping and thinking both analytically and intuitively (Micheli et al., 2019). Companies understandably use Design Thinking to solve all kinds of problems, mainly to create the best possible product, services and experiences, but also attempting to solve large organizational problems (Coughlan et al., 2017).
The concept of Design Thinking
How does Design Thinking relate to culture?
As Design Thinking are both the methodes, but also the thinking one applies, it is heavily interdependent on culture, as culture is often defined as a toolkit one draws the symbols, stories, rituals, beliefs, ideologies and daily practice one used in everyday behavior, or as ‘how we do things around here’ (Swidler, 1986). In one sense Design Thinking is a certain toolkit, with various beliefs and behaviors, hence a certain culture. Some scholars also talk about industry registers, as a common cultural toolkit for an industry, unique for that industry. In this sense Design Thinking is the industry register, or the toolkit, of concepts used and accepted as appropriate in the design industry to interpret situations and create strategies (Rindova et al., 2010). So, to incorporate Design Thinking and create the absolute best products, services and solutions in general, you need a culture to accommodate it. Bad news, you might be thinking, as you know culture is notoriously difficult to change. Well, hold on.
Collaboration is an essential part of a culture encompassing Design Thinking.
Culture as often visualized in the literature
Wait, so I cannot change culture?
Luckily, just as there is literature suggesting that cultural change is almost impossible, or very difficult, there are also studies which indicate that this is not necessarily true. There are practitioners who have successfully changed cultures. The assumption is that by changing the outer layer, changing the behavior, the inner beliefs and eventually the core values and identity will follow (Shook, 2010).
Cultural enrichment is another term describing the transfer and adoption of cultural resources and behavior repertoire from one industry registry to another, and is essentially what adopting Design Thinking, or any other behaviors for that matter, is (Rindova et al., 2010). This is also empirically found to be true for changing a culture into a Design Thinking culture as Design Thinking tools appear to influence and develop cultures related to experimentation and openness to failure, central aspects of a culture that emphasizes Design Thinking. Similarly, collaborative and experimental cultures support the use of prototyping, co creation and consumer journey mapping, while cultures defined by productivity and performance inhibit the use of such tools. The opposite reaction also appears to be true, a design culture promotes the use of Design Thinking tools (Elsbach & Stigliani, 2018).
This translates to work practices being able to change culture, and culture being able to change work practices. Central to this is the idea of culture being a way to make sense of day-to-day practices, which resonates with the previous mentioned visualizations of culture, with the values guiding the behavior (Elsbach & Stigliani, 2018).
Cultural change is not impossible Shook, (2010)
Central to changing a culture successfully is the redefinition of identity (Rindova et al., 2010). Essential to this is sensemaking, both on an individual and organizational level. Is the glue that links culture to everyday practice, and is consequently essential to the ability to transform a culture into a Design Thinking culture (Elsbach & Stigliani, 2018;Rindova et al., 2010). Sensemaking is the key to changing all the levels of the culture, not just the repertoire, actually, sensemaking, or ‘why we do what we do’ is a good definition of what culture is and does for an individual and an organization (Elsbach & Stigliani, 2018).
Fortunately, you can change culture!
Is design thinking always effective?
No, not necessarily always, Design Thinking methods are great at innovative solutions to complex problems, but it is not necessarily great for optimizing and to streamline businesses who need to be effective and stable (Kolko, 2015). Like any tool, Design Thinking methods should be used consciously and with the limitations of the methods in mind, it is for example great for idea generation and selection but not necessarily during implementation. And too much use of brainstorming sessions, for example, might actually be counterproductive (Seidel & Fixson, 2013). Having a awesome toolkit is after all not that useful if you don’t know how to use the tools properly. Just like a skilled craftsman you need to know which tools are best for each task, and which is most effective at what job.
Recap: Design Thinking and culture
- Design Thinking is a term used to describe various methods, practices and a particular way of thinking traditionally used in the Design Industry, but increasingly used in a plethora of businesses to solve complex tasks, often centred around the human experience.
- These include ethnographic methods, personas, journey mapping, brainstorming, mind map, visualization, prototyping and experiments.
- Culture and the behaviors and everyday tools and practices one uses are interchangeably intertwined as the underlying cultural identity and values informs the repertoire of beliefs and actions.
- Ultimately changing these can be hard, but certainly not impossible, studies support the notion that the two affect each other, integrate new practices and the values and identity will follow.
- Central to a successful integration of new cultural repertoire is the re-identification and sensemaking of the new practice.
- Using these practices should, like any others, be used and implemented purposefully, and most likely as each culture is different and even ephemeral, in the sense that it is ever changing, a universal approach is unlikely, and each culture will need its unique approaches .
The author of the text is Stian Kjelstrup Jacobsen.
Canato, A., & Ravasi, D. (2015). Managing long-lasting cultural changes. Organizational Dynamics, 44(1), 75–82.
Coughlan, P., Suri, J. F., & Canales, K. (2007). Prototypes as (Design) Tools for Behavioral and Organizational Change: A Design-Based Approach to Help Organizations Change Work Behaviors. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 43(1), 122–134.
Elsbach, K. D., & Stigliani, I. (2018). Design Thinking and Organizational Culture: A Review and Framework for Future Research. Journal of Management, 44(6), 2274–2306.
Kolko, J. (2015, September 1). Design Thinking Comes of Age. Harvard Business Review.
Micheli, P., Wilner, S. J. S., Bhatti, S. H., Mura, M., & Beverland, M. B. (2019). Doing Design Thinking: Conceptual Review, Synthesis, and Research Agenda. Journal of Product Innovation Management, 36(2), 124–148.
Rindova, V., Dalpiaz, E., & Ravasi, D. (2010). A Cultural Quest: A Study of Organizational Use of New Cultural Resources in Strategy Formation. Organization Science, 22(2), 413–431.
Seidel, V. P., & Fixson, S. K. (2013). Adopting Design Thinking in Novice Multidisciplinary Teams: The Application and Limits of Design Methods and Reflexive Practices. Journal of Product Innovation Management, 30(S1), 19–33.
Shook—How to Change a Culture Lesson From NummI.pdf. (n.d.). Retrieved September 2, 2021, from https://www.asenta.es/src/uploads/2019/06/How-to-change-a-Culture-Lessons-from-Nummi.pdf
Swidler, A. (1986). Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies. American Sociological Review, 51(2), 273–286.
Need help mapping out your organization culture?
Contact us to plan our first meeting!
You may be interested
6 Strategies to be part of the green growthThis blog post aims to explore the concept of green growth and provide actionable strategies for companies to integrate sustainability into their core practices.
What is an innovation culture made of? Unravelling the five essential elements.In this blog post, we'll explore how companies can unlock the innovation potential across the organization and why is it so beneficial. In the end…
Keeping up with rapidly evolving technologiesIn this blog post, we will explore the challenges companies face when keeping up with rapidly evolving technologies and how to overcome these challenges. In…
How to improve transnational cooperation?In this blog post, we will offer an insight of transnational cooperation that we have gained through our internationl projects. We will also provide practical…
Collaboration as a driver for sustainable innovationIn this blog and video, we will explore the importance of collaboration and the benefits it can bring to sustainable innovation. In the insight, we…
Unlocking the innovation potential of employeesIn this blog post, we'll explore how companies can unlock the innovation potential across the organization and why is it so beneficial. In the end…
What is driving the health sector today?In this article we look closer at the trends in the health sector in 2023. We dicuss the market drivers and the investments of Big…
Discover the power and potential of ChatGPTIn this blog post, we will explore the capabilities and potential uses of ChatGPT, as well as some of the societal challenges it raises.
What is the sustainability problem and why should your company care?In this article we look closer at: What the sustainability problem is, How does it impact your company, and how sustainability efforts can benefit your…
How can an established company innovate as a startup?In this article we look closer at: Ambidextrous organizations, Lean Startup, Design Thinking and Agile work methodologies.
How to align sustainability and profitability?In this article we look closer at what research says about sustainability and profitability and 3 easy steps to help you integrate sustainability efforts into…
How to overcome 3 biggest obstacles to innovation success?In this blog post we look closer in to the biggest obstacles for innovation, and how to overcome them. In the end of the article,…
Home Office and Innovation, is it possible?
In this article we discuss: Does working from home damage innovation? How management needs to adapt? Possible solution: The actor-oriented structure Additional tips to succeeding […]
CO2 Utslippene har ingen grenser!For at vi skal lykkes å nå målene om nullutslipp, må Norge dele kunnskapene internasjonalt.
Applying for EEA & Norway Grants? Here are our 5 tips!EEA and Norway Grants ? Looking for a Norwegian partner? Here are some tips, dos and don’ts from our experience!
How do organizations digitally transform?
Digitalization is not the same as innovation, but digitalization can be an important factor that will inflame innovation. Many innovations resulted from digitalization through enabling […]
What have Design thinking and Culture in common when it comes to innovation?
Design thinking and culture Does your company deliver services, or deal with customers of any kind? Do you have employees operating machines and tools? The […]
5 Key Areas where innovation is transforming fintech
Fostering innovation is key to growing your business and necessary to stay ahead of the competition. The two sectors that spent the most on R&D […]
Do you know the difference between radical and disruptive innovation?
Did Apple disrupt the market? Did the launch of iPhone make Apple a market disruptor?
To excel in innovation endeavors: 3 things to learn from the Covid crisis!
3 important tips you can learn from the Covid-19 crisis to excel in your innovation endeavors!
Do all your innovation solutions make money? Here are 3 steps on how to create a sustainable innovation portfolio!
Would you like to have a portfolio of innovative solutions that do not make money?
Persistent innovators and how to act now (ref. Covid-19)
In this post we cover: What is in common among persistent innovators during and after the 2008 crisis? How will the Covid-19 crisis affect […]
Do crises boost innovation or is this just a myth?
How can we expect that the (coronavirus) crisis will affect innovation output?
Definition and Types of Innovation
Innovation is a very frequently used term. Everyone talks about innovation. We hear phrases like disruptive innovation, incremental innovation, architectural innovation, radical innovation… But how […]
Reacting to the Crisis: 5 steps to Success
In less than three months, the spreading of the coronavirus has proven to be catastrophic for hundreds of thousands of people. At the time of […]
Our times of high uncertainty….
Coronavirus (or Covid-19) has caused the world to turn upside down in a very short time. As of last week, the picture in Norway has […]
Våger Norge egentlig å gå ut av komfort sone?
SSB sin statistikk viser at i Norge var det ca. 65% av norske foretak som hadde noen type av innovasjonsaktivitet i perioden 2014-2016. Dette er […]
Når Sesam Parkering AS sovner bak rattet
Sesam Parkering AS gikk konkurs forrige uke. De hadde de beste parkeringsplassene i Bergen sentrum og den nærmeste parkeringsplassen til hoved terminalen på Flesland. De […]
Bergen kommune og Digital Kultur Plattform
BT har skrevet et innlegg om Bergen Kommune (BK) sitt initiativ «Digital Kultur Plattform». Jeg har ledet forprosjektet (gjennom engasjement i Capgemini) i vår og […]
Music Tech Fest – an event full of inspiration and innovation
The city of Bergen invited Michela Magas for visit in May as a part of the Festspillene[i] and launching of the Bergen Nå(Now) project. I […]
5 Elements of the Innovation Process
Innovation. Innovation has become a buzz word of today’s business. Google search results say that the word “innovation” has been used more than half a […]